In order to be a good psychologist we need to be able to understand not only our own culture, but also very different ways of living that the ones we have. Below I am going to explain the basic ideas of Dani culture, a really interesting society that will leave you astonished.
The Grand
Valley Dani of Irian Jaya Indonesia has a very peculiar sexual life. Even the
most curious anthropologist become amazed with the sexual practices that this
culture has (even though they are accustomed to seeing the most strange things
that you can imagine).
Dani culture
is not interested in sex. They do not do much energetic activity and that has
created a very low interest in having a complete sexual life. They have no
interest in it. To go deeper into their sexuality, we can see that they have a
really long postpartum abstinence, 5 years of not having any type of sex. This surprising fact has been studied by many
anthropologists, psychologists and other social sciences to understand why does
Dani culture have this behavior. Saucier, which was a psychologist and
anthropologist, studied this phenomenon and he discovered that a very long
postpartum abstinence was one year (something not common and difficult to maintain
for monogamous couples) in general in societies. In order to know why Dani culture has this 5-year abstinence
we need to know why it was introduced in the culture, and how it was maintained
throughout the years, concluding that it was based on social structure.
Nowadays, Freudian assumptions about
sexuality are day a day knowledge, they are seen as a reference of studies and
ways of thinking, so things that differ from these are normally seen as
something strange. The
studies and assumptions made on the Dani culture are really difficult to
demonstrate and they are not reliable as more proof is needed in order to show
that the results are true. This investigation is based on what people say about
their sexual lives, what they do or what they feel, but it is very difficult to
know if what they are saying is true, as you cant be 100% sure of what someone
else feels or does.
Furthermore,
anthropologist want to discover the range of human sexual behaviour, and the
Dani culture is going to help to do this as it will show if sexual behaviour is
something innate or culturally learned. Now they are not only investigating the
postpartum abstinence, but also many other trades that would help to discover
more about sexual life in different cultures and in Dani’s one.
To prove
that the Dani culture is telling the truth with its postpartum sexual abstinence,
we can see two-mayor evidence. The first one is the social one. Dani culture does not have much private life,
everybody knows everything about everyone and keeping a secret is very
difficult. Furthermore, no one talked about breaking the rule of abstinence, as
no one broke it because it would have been a mayor issue that everyone would
talk about and no one mentioned anything about it. Secondly, we can see that
siblings are at least five years of age apart from each other, which again
proves the point that they are telling the truth. To control the postpartum
sexual abstinence there is no control or punishment, the only bad thing that
could happen to them is a punishment from ghosts. Dani's
citizens do not suffer stress, depression or pain because of the celibacy.
There is also some interesting
data to take into account.
Firstly,
even though they don’t practice sexual activities much, they are able to maintain
the population. Women do not have many children. Dani men talked about
abortion, but there is not prove that it occurred. Furthermore, women talked
about contraceptive plants, but again there was not enough evidence of it to prove
its use. There is no infanticide.
Moreover,
extramarital sex is really strange. If it happens it would cause a great deal
of problems in society as it is not well seen. Furthermore, married couples can’t
have sex until there is a ceremony for it and two years of marriage and living
together have passed. Also, to get married is a very long process as weddings
are held every four to six years.Homosexuality
is not seen at all in the Dani culture, if two men sleep together it is not
seen as something sexual.
For more
surprise, the Dani culture uses the penis gourd not for any sexual reasons, not
even the different sizes and shapes of the penis have sexual connotations. The
only example we can see of sexuality in Dani culture is in teenagers, which
create songs with sexual content, drawings and string figures. These represent
the only explicit sexuality in Dani culture. Conclusions have been made that
Dani people are conservatives because their rules permit them to act in
different and comfortable ways for them without changing their rules.
Furthermore, they are really healthy people. Dani's civilization is not
emotional. They don’t express lots of emotion, don’t get into conflicts and rarely
show anger.
Freud said that everybody has an innate
amount of sexual energy that must be wasted; it would be used in other forms if
you do not use it. Following the rule, Dani culture must have a really high
level of intellectual or ascetic achievements, but none of this happens in this
society. Thanks to this, anthropologists came to the
conclusion that the nature of human sexuality is determined by cultural and
social circumstances and not Freudian ideas. Gagon and Simon made a study investigating
the nature of human sexuality discovering places where there is lots of
affection and nearly no sex and vice versa which challenges Freud’s conclusions.
Dani is a
low energy system, in other words, they don’t do activities that require much
energy, neither thinks a lot about complex things or use energy as other
societies do. This does not mean that their level of life is worst, in fact
they are healthy, happy, relaxed people with a high quality of life. Even at wartime
they spend most of the time relaxed talking more than fighting. They do not
even have much anger towards the enemy.
Finally, Dani’s
way of behaving isn’t the normal one. There are two main factors of why this happens: environment
and culture. The former shows that they do not have seasons, days or even months,
which gives them a completely different way of life. The latter refers to Dani
culture mixing with others, something that did not happen until 1954 that has
made them have this interesting culture.
They do not have any stress, not even babies in their first years of
life. We cannot prove that these factors are the ones that make Dani’s have
this sexual life the only thing we can conclude is that Dani culture has a low
level of sexual life.
Qué estupendo blog, Elisa. Tiene un nombre magnífico y una muy bonita presentación.
ReplyDeleteAdemás, me ha interesado mucho este post sobre los Dani, de los que no había oído hablar nunca.
Lamento no tener mejor nivel de inglés para no perderme nada de lo que escribes.
Enhorabuena